Bananas and Duct Tape – Understanding Cattelan’s Banana Masterpiece

Imagine walking into a room and seeing a single banana taped to a wall with silver duct tape. Now imagine that this simple, unassuming display sold for a jaw-dropping USD 5.2m. Yes, that’s the story of Comedian by Maurizio Cattelan, the banana that took the art world (and the internet) by storm.

The DIY Price Tag

If you were inspired by this avant-garde piece and wanted to recreate it, you might head to your local shop. A banana costs about 40p, and a roll of silver duct tape will set you back about £3.50, maybe even less at a corner shop. For less than a fiver, you could have your own masterpiece. But before you start dreaming of auction houses and six-figure paydays, let’s talk about why Cattelan’s version fetched such an astronomical price. Spoiler alert – it wasn’t because of the banana or the tape.

The Value of an Idea

The definition of Modern Art
“I Could Do That!”
“Yeah, But You Didn’t”

This is where Cattelan’s genius lies. It’s not in the materials, but in the concept. He took the mundane and elevated it to the extraordinary, using wit and absurdity to challenge how we value art.

The piece is a commentary on consumerism, fleeting beauty, and even the absurdity of the art market itself. Its genius lies not in the banana but in the audacity to sell the banana as art. Buyers weren’t paying for the fruit, they were paying for Cattelan’s signature, his reputation, and, perhaps most importantly, the idea behind it.

Fame, Name, and Concept

Art in the contemporary world is often a mix of who created it, what it represents, and how it fits into the cultural conversation. Cattelan isn’t just any artist; he’s renowned for provocative works that blur the lines between art and satire. When you buy a piece like Comedian, you’re buying into that reputation. It’s not just a banana taped to the wall, it’s a piece of Cattelan’s legacy.

Why Does Contemporary Art Fetch Such High Prices?

The astronomical prices in contemporary art often baffle people because it often seems to defy conventional notions of value. Let’s face it, it can be hard to reconcile the apparent lack of complexity or craftsmanship with the astronomical price tags. We tend to instinctively associate value with labour or material cost, so when those elements seem minimal, the price feels unjustifiable. It’s a clash of perspectives where, on the one side, art is seen as an investment or intellectual endeavour and on the other, through the lens of tangible worth or aesthetic enjoyment. This divide is as much about cultural understanding as it is about economics, leaving many to wonder whether it’s about the art itself, or the story we tell about it?

LET ME EXPLAIN

Scarcity and Exclusivity

Even if the artwork seems simple, it’s often unique or part of a limited series. Owning it signals exclusivity and access to a rarefied world.

Reputation and Brand

Just as luxury goods trade on their brand, artists with a strong name in the art world command higher prices. A banana on a wall by Joe Bloggs wouldn’t sell for £10, but by Cattelan? That’s a different story.

Conceptual Brilliance

Contemporary art often values the idea over execution. In this case, the banana is a placeholder for a broader commentary, and buyers are investing in that intellectual narrative.

The Market Itself

Art has become a form of investment. Wealthy collectors are as much speculators as they are admirers, often betting that a piece will increase in value.

Similarly, in finance, raw materials and labour form the basis of value, but markets create additional worth through branding, futures, and perceived potential.

You gotta Speculate to Accumulate

In a past life, so to speak, I worked for the giant JP Morgan in Paris (now JPMorgan Chase) so I’m going to throw in a commentary on the financialisation of art or the turning of art into a commodity, a tradable asset class that gains value from market dynamics.

Buyers of high-end art are often investing in more than the artwork, they’re investing in its future value, its cultural significance, and the status it brings.

It’s exactly the same principle behind financial derivatives where a product is only as valuable as the market decides. Derivatives don’t have inherent worth but instead represent the potential to gain or lose value based on a broader system of trust, reputation, and market forces. The art market, like Wall Street, thrives on speculation, creating a feedback loop where perceived value drives actual value.

So, What’s the Point?

The next time you walk past a banana or unroll some duct tape, remember Comedian. It’s a reminder that art isn’t always about what’s on the wall. It’s about the conversation it sparks. Whether you see it as a profound critique or an elaborate prank, one thing’s for sure: you’re still talking about it. And isn’t that what art is meant to do?

---